This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Without a doubt, the heavy rockfish, that once mace you can fish in the STV Contest. I laughed so hard, I showed it off to all my guildies, who already knew about it, but proceeded to indulge in my mindless drooling anyway. ^_^ What can I say, I freaking love Blizz's sense of humor.
definitely when i fished up my first http://www.wowhead.com/?item=27388
The item I got that made me go "OMG! THIS IS AWESOME!" was the first green item I ever got on my Troll Priest. I just started WoW that day and so far was rockin' with mostly whites and a few greys, but when I saw that robe (http://www.wowhead.com/?item=16606#reward-from) I went crazy trying to get it, which suprislingly wasn't really easy because I had to buy a skill and back then 1 silver wasn't cheap. Anyway the work I had to do to get that robe paid off because, from that moment forward I could take on any challenge! (...Or so I thought :P)
Oh man, the first time I went into AV and looted my first Broken I.W.I.N. Button, it overruled all of my other loot on the ep1k scale by far. I was actually in hysterics for minuites imagining that sorry sap who was spamming his IWIN button.
Due to my work schedule, I'm more of a casual player. But then I discovered raiding. I watched with dismay as group after group turned me down for my gear not being good enough to raid with. My current guild took me on and I got more good gear... but the most epic for me would be getting my first Tier 4 token. Granted, it was for gloves, but it was something!
Halberd of Smiting from ZG back when i was 60, best polearm skin ever btw!
I can easily say that after hours of farming and ruining my faction, the most epic piece of loot i ever received in the entirety of my lifetime was the Pet Rock. It looks happy!
My most epic drop was in stratholme. I am not really sure how my group and I ended up in Stratholme but we did. So being there we try to go for Hearthsinger Forresten. Well we go and 2 people in the group decide to run the other way. So we are left with a healer a tank and a DPS (me). Somehow with even the healer running out of mana and our mage bubble tank both running out of man from mobs before he falls. What drops? Yeah the Piccolo of the flaming fire. Epic run "epic" drop.
Vial of tears, I found it to be hilarious xD